Core Principles
Intermediate12 min read

Multiple Offers & Counteroffers

How to present, compare, and counter competing offers without creating an accidental contract.

Syllabus N-V-C · verified 2026-08-16

Contracts is the heaviest national domain (about 19% of the exam). Multiple-offer and counteroffer mechanics are Apply-level items: one wrong step can bind a seller, reject a good offer, or look like undisclosed dual agency.

Presenting offers

  • Present every written offer promptly — even if it looks weak, late, or arrives after a verbal 'we have a deal.'
  • A seller may accept, reject, counter, or let an offer expire. Silence is not acceptance.
  • Do not tell one buyer the terms of another offer unless the seller authorizes that disclosure.
  • If the listing agreement or brokerage policy requires a specific presentation method, follow it.

Counteroffers and backup offers

Counteroffer
A rejection of the original offer plus a new offer on different terms. The original cannot later be accepted unless it is revived in writing.
Multiple counteroffers
Sending the same counter to more than one buyer at once can create two contracts if more than one buyer accepts. Use a form that says acceptance is not binding until the seller picks one in writing.
Backup offer
A secondary contract that becomes primary only if the first contract fails. It should say so in writing.
Highest and best
A seller request that competing buyers submit their strongest terms by a deadline. It is an invitation to offer, not a contract.
Revocation
An offeror may withdraw an offer any time before it is accepted, unless the offer is an option supported by consideration.

Exam trap: a counteroffer kills the original. If the seller later says 'we'll take your first price,' that is a new offer the buyer must accept. Another trap: telling Buyer B the exact number Buyer A offered, without seller authorization, can breach confidentiality.

Key takeaways

  • Present all written offers promptly; the seller decides which to accept, reject, or counter.
  • A counteroffer rejects the original — it cannot be accepted later unless revived.
  • Multiple counters need language that prevents two binding contracts.
  • Do not shop offer terms between buyers unless the seller authorizes it.

Practice this

Review the “National Contracts” deckTake the “National Contracts” quiz